Exxon Mobil (XOM) is now facing one of Wall Street’s least forgiving rules. You can register a fantastic quarter, like Exxon Mobil, and the stock will sell anyway.
That is what happened on April 8, when Exxon, Chevron (CVX), and the rest of the energy sector dropped hard after a U.S.-Iran ceasefire knocked the wind out of the sails of the energy sector. The so-called “war premium” is perhaps out of the picture after the U.S. and Iran started talks in Pakistan, opening a transit corridor as the two sides meet for tense negotiations.
There is no deal yet, BBC notes. However, the two parties negotiating is reason enough for many to jump with joy.
Brent crude slid to $90.40 a barrel, its lowest level in nearly a month, and the trade that had carried energy stocks higher all quarter now looks a lot less certain.
That reversal mattered because energy for the last few weeks is a clear winner. According to Reuters, theS&P 500 Energy Index went up more than 37% in the first quarter, while the S&P 500 as a whole fell about 4.6%.
Exxon rose 41% in the quarter, according to Barron’s, while Chevron rose 36%. This wasn’t a normal pullback. The market wondered whether the easiest part of the oil trade was already over.
Exxon’s quarter may look good, but still not matter much
That same day, Exxon added an important twist. The company said in its April 8 filing that problems in Qatar and the UAE would cut global oil-equivalent production in the first quarter by about 6% compared to the fourth quarter of 2025.
In 2025, those Middle East assets made up about 20% of Exxon’s total oil production around the world. The company also said the disruption would lower global Energy Products throughput by about 2%.
More Oil and Gas:
- The world’s biggest gas field matters just as much as oil right now
- Goldman Sachs reveals top oil stocks to buy for 2026
- U.S. economy will show resilience, despite rising oil prices
That does not mean Exxon delivered a weak quarter. Reuters reported that higher oil and gas prices could lead to an uptick in upstream earnings by roughly $1.4 billion from the prior quarter. The same report, though, said that timing effects related to derivatives and cargoes delayed by the conflict would cost downstream earnings about $5.3 billion.
Reuters also said the earnings snapshot showed about $5 billion, or $1.20 a share, compared to adjusted earnings of $7.3 billion, or $1.71 a share, in the fourth quarter. On May 1, Exxon will release its full first-quarter results.
That is the stock’s main problem. Exxon may still be able to show that the rise in commodity prices helped the company, but investors are already preparing for a harder second quarter.
A “good” quarter can stop being a reason to own the stock when the market starts to price what crude does next, instead of what it did last quarter. This is an educated guess based on the drop in oil, the sector sell-off, and Exxon’s own earnings setup.
Adams/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Why oil’s next move matters more than Exxon’s last quarter
The bearish argument against Exxon is straightforward. If the ceasefire holds and traffic through the Strait of Hormuz continues to normalize, one of the biggest tailwinds supporting oil prices starts to disappear.
Market strategists were already warning that sentiment would still be driven by headline risk and that any sign the truce was “hanging by a thread” could quickly change people’s risk appetite.
But the new information since April 8 makes the story more complicated than just a decline in oil prices. Barclays noted on April 9 that its baseline still says Brent should average $85 a barrel in 2026, according to Reuters, but only if flows through the Strait of Hormuz get back to normal quickly.
The bank said flows stayed low even after the ceasefire, with disruptions estimated at 13 million to 14 million barrels per day. There is also a warning that delays or new escalations could cause prices to rise from current levels.
That tension was even clearer by April 12. Reuters said long talks in Islamabad did not lead to a breakthrough between the U.S. and Iran, which put more pressure on the two-week ceasefire.
At the same time, there were early signs of progress. Saudi Arabia said it had restored the East-West pipeline to its full capacity of 7 million barrels per day. Three fully loaded supertankers also passed through the Strait of Hormuz on Saturday, April 11, the first such transit since the ceasefire, Reuters reported.
Exxon Mobil stock is now a volatility trade
The disruption in the Strait leaves Exxon Mobil stock in an unusual bind. It is still one of the biggest oil companies, and its first-quarter numbers could show how much the rise in energy prices caused by the war helped the business. But the easy, clean bullish setup is no longer there.
Now, investors have to deal with production problems, accounting noise, weak diplomacy, and an oil market that can change quickly based on a single headline.
The cleaner way to tell this story is also the sharper one: Exxon is no longer just a bet on high oil prices. It’s a bet on how long the chaos in Hormuz will last.
If flows return to normal, the sector’s huge gains in the first quarter may start to seem too big. If diplomacy fails again and problems keep occurring, the oil trade could start up again. In any case, Wall Street is no longer seeing Exxon as a clear winner.
Key takeaways for Exxon investors
- Exxon Mobil stock fell with the broader energy sector after a ceasefire headline knocked oil prices sharply lower on April 8.
- Exxon said problems in the Middle East would cut production in the first quarter by about 6%. These assets made up about 20% of the company’s global oil-equivalent output in 2025.
- Higher commodity prices could help upstream earnings, but timing issues and delayed shipments could put a lot of pressure on downstream results.
- Brent will average $85 in 2026, but only if Hormuz normalizes quickly. If it takes longer, prices could stay high.
- Shipping was starting to pick up again on April 12, but the ceasefire looked weak because talks had broken down.
Related: Oil traders are seeing something in Iran’s truce that stocks aren’t
